What observers say
“The United States is the American dream, that’s what they call it. But no, it wasn’t like that,” said J, a Venezuelan immigrant whose life was upended when federal agents took his wife in February 2026. This poignant statement encapsulates the feelings of many in Baldwin, Wisconsin, where the recent surge in deportations has left the community grappling with fear and uncertainty.
In Baldwin, a town that is over 95% white and leans Republican, the immigrant population has been growing in recent years. However, the recent actions by the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) have led to significant unrest. More than 50 individuals were taken by federal agents during a peak in January and February 2026, raising questions about the targeting of this small town.
Residents have expressed their concerns about safety and community cohesion. Many have reported feeling unsafe, prompting the formation of mutual aid networks to support families affected by deportations. “This is a super important fight. I care very deeply about what happens in Baldwin and what kind of community I’m part of,” stated Jenelle Ludwig Krause, a local advocate. Her words reflect a growing sentiment among residents who are rallying against the perceived injustices of immigration enforcement.
Julie N, another Baldwin resident, remarked, “I really think that they came into small towns thinking there would be no resistance.” This sentiment resonates with many who feel that the federal government has underestimated the resolve of small-town communities. As ICE continues its operations, local residents are increasingly vocal about their opposition to the agency’s tactics.
According to ICE, as of July 2024, there were 435,000 unauthorized immigrants with criminal convictions in the United States who were not in custody. The agency has arrested 752 non-citizens convicted of murder and 1,693 convicted of sexual assault as part of its enforcement efforts. However, the number of deportations occurring in Baldwin and surrounding areas remains unclear, with details unconfirmed.
Local business owners are also feeling the impact of these deportation actions. Jairo Sarango, owner of EcuaMarket, reported a steep decline in business as customers feel uncomfortable leaving their homes. The atmosphere of fear has permeated the community, affecting not just those directly involved with ICE but also the broader population.
Questions have arisen regarding police involvement with immigration enforcement in Baldwin. Residents are concerned about the collaboration between local law enforcement and federal agents, which has further fueled distrust within the community. The Department of Homeland Security has stated, “Every day, DHS enforces the laws of the nation across the country including in Minnesota and Wisconsin to keep Americans safe,” but many locals feel that this enforcement is coming at the cost of their community’s safety and well-being.
As Baldwin continues to navigate the complexities of immigration enforcement, the community remains on edge. With uncertainties surrounding the targeting of their town and the exact number of deportations, residents are left to ponder the future of their community and the ongoing fight for justice amidst a backdrop of fear and resistance.