On May 4, 2026, Sam Allberry resigned from his pastoral positions at Immanuel Nashville and The Keller Center for Cultural Apologetics after admitting to an inappropriate relationship with another man. This revelation has led to his disqualification from ministry, a significant event in the Christian community.
The Gospel Coalition’s Board of Directors stated, “TGC was informed yesterday by Sam Allberry about ‘an inappropriate relationship with another man a few years ago’ and that an announcement would be made today at Immanuel Church regarding his resignation as a pastor.” This admission has shocked many, particularly because Allberry has been a vocal figure on issues surrounding same-sex attraction within the context of Christian faith.
That context matters because Allberry is not just any pastor; he is known for his books such as ‘Is God Anti-Gay?’ and ‘Biblical Manhood.’ His writings have sparked discussions about sexuality and faith, making this situation even more poignant.
Allberry’s past openness about his own same-sex attraction has resonated with many in the church. Yet, this admission contradicts the teachings he has long espoused. The elders at Immanuel Nashville acted swiftly to disqualify him from ministry following this revelation.
In response to these events, The Gospel Coalition removed all of Allberry’s content from its website and social media channels. They expressed emotional distress over the situation, stating, “We are heartbroken over this news, and we continue to pray for Sam, Immanuel Church, and everyone affected.” This reflects the deep connections within the community and the impact of such a resignation.
Allberry’s journey began when he became a Christian at 18 in England. His rise to prominence included various speaking engagements and leadership roles that positioned him as a key voice in contemporary Christian discussions on sexuality.
The fallout from this incident will likely reverberate through both Immanuel Nashville and The Gospel Coalition. As leaders grapple with the implications of Allberry’s actions, they face critical questions about accountability, grace, and the complexities of human relationships within their communities.