What football thinks of USMNT: ‘The best in many, many years’ or needing World Cup ‘miracle’ - The Athletic - The New York TimesWhat football thinks of USMNT: ‘The best in many, many years’ or needing World Cup ‘miracle’ - The Athletic - The New York Times

The United States Men’s National Team (USMNT) has generated considerable discussion regarding its performance at the current World Cup, with opinions divided among prominent football figures on how far the team can advance. Following their opening victory against Paraguay, former USMNT coach Jurgen Klinsmann described the team’s first 45 minutes as the best in many years. Klinsmann, who coached the U.S. team from 2011 to 2016, noted the team’s ability to set a high standard for themselves in the tournament. This initial display gained further significance after Paraguay later eliminated Germany to reach the last 16.

Mauricio Pochettino’s side has created a notable buzz around men’s football in the country, sweeping aside their first opponent. The team’s journey to the Round of 32 match against Bosnia-Herzegovina has prompted various football personalities to assess their prospects. While the USMNT has advanced past the group stage in the modern era of the men’s World Cup, they have not progressed beyond the quarter-finals.

Expectations and Tactical Approach

Brazilian icon Kaka expressed confidence even before the tournament began, predicting the USMNT would reach the semi-finals, citing excitement and motivation as key factors. Kaka, a 2002 World Cup winner with Brazil, believes the team possesses good players and a strong coach, making them ready for at least a semi-final appearance. However, others hold more cautious views.

Philipp Lahm, captain of Germany’s 2014 World Cup-winning team, suggested that home crowd support could carry the USMNT to the quarter-finals. Rio Ferdinand, who reached the quarter-finals with England, stated he would be surprised if they reached the semi-finals, depending on their route, but acknowledged they have already exceeded expectations. Ferdinand praised the team’s energy and emotional play, calling them a team America can be proud of.

Rene Meulensteen, formerly an assistant at Manchester United, believes that while the U.S. is playing with a lot of emotion as the host country, this can only take them so far. He sees Bosnia as a beatable opponent and suggests the USMNT could potentially defeat Belgium in the last 16, describing that as an even contest. Meulensteen considers a semi-final appearance for America an “absolute miracle,” especially given the strength of teams like France, whom the U.S. would potentially face at that stage.

Jay DeMerit, a member of the U.S. team that reached the last 16 in 2010, thinks the U.S. can reach the quarters. He views the Bosnia game as winnable, along with the subsequent potential match, and highlights the advantage of playing at home.

The team’s tactical evolution under Pochettino has been a key talking point. After a 2-0 loss to South Korea in a friendly last September, Pochettino implemented a tactical tweak at halftime, switching to a back-five system. This system was also used in a 2-0 win against Japan. While results over the past year have been mixed, including wins against Australia, Paraguay, and Uruguay, and losses to Belgium and Portugal, Pochettino’s approach has made the team dangerous.

Klinsmann observed the team’s effective counter-press tactic, which he described as logical and efficient. He noted the team’s ability to “squeeze the lemon” by quickly winning the ball back in tight spaces, a strategy he believes gives them confidence and the capacity to challenge any opponent when playing with rhythm and aggression.

Fan Engagement and Betting Trends

The USMNT’s performances have ignited significant fan engagement, with stadiums like SoFi and Lumen Field in Seattle seeing vibrant atmospheres. This enthusiasm marks a shift from earlier periods, such as the 2024 Copa America exit and a largely empty SoFi for a 2025 CONCACAF Nations League semi-final loss to Panama.

Oddsmakers at American sportsbooks have noted substantial support for the USA in World Cup betting. According to Mark Bickerdike, head of soccer trading at Caesars Sports, there was patriotic money on the USMNT even before the tournament, which increased significantly after their strong start. For the USMNT’s Round of 32 match against Bosnia-Herzegovina, wagering has been particularly high.

The market for the match initially saw the three-way moneyline open at USA -190/Bosnia and Herzegovina +525/Draw +295. However, these odds were adjusted, reflecting an initial overreaction to the USA’s 3-2 loss to Türkiye in their final group match. The odds later settled at USA -275/Bosnia and Herzegovina +750/Draw +370. In the “To Qualify” market, 91.4% of the money was placed on the USA, indicating strong public confidence.

Despite the loss to Türkiye, which caused the USMNT’s futures odds to slide slightly, customer support has remained robust. The USMNT is currently among the top teams in World Cup futures, sharing the co-ninth choice position with Colombia at Caesars, partly due to upset losses by Germany and the Netherlands.

Leander Schaerlaeckens, author and journalist, described the USMNT’s play in their first two World Cup games, particularly against Paraguay, as the most creative and best he had seen from the team. He noted that Pochettino has brought back the traditional U.S. traits of hard running, organization, and feistiness, while layering tactical acumen and technical ability. Schaerlaeckens highlighted the team’s completeness and the development of technical players, attributing some of this to a combination of luck and the legacy of birthright citizenship, citing players like Flo Balogun, Malik Tillman, and Sergiño Dest. The team’s current approach, marked by a sense of fun and confidence, makes them enjoyable to watch.

The USMNT’s ability to sustain their intensity and depth will be crucial as they face the physical challenge of Bosnia, a team that eliminated four-time winners Italy in qualifying. The match against Bosnia-Herzegovina is scheduled for Wednesday evening at 8 p.m. ET.

USMNT players celebrate together after scoring at the World Cup
USMNT players celebrate together after scoring at the World Cup Credit: nytimes.com

Source: nytimes.com

By Jordan Hayes

Sports reporter covering football, basketball and international competitions.